Evaluate Fit & Function

 

IN THIS SECTION


“I have not failed, I’ve just found 10,000 ways that won’t work.”
— Thomas Edison, Inventor


When designing solutions, it’s important to test your ideas and learn from what doesn’t work in order to make your designs better. Nobody gets everything right on the first try. Here we’ll guide you through the key activities of the Evaluate step in the Biomimicry Design Spiral.

EVALUATE

Assess the design concept(s) for how well they meet the criteria and constraints of the design challenge and fit into Earth’s systems. Consider technical and business model feasibility. Refine and revisit previous steps as needed to produce a viable solution.

This step is all about assessment. Your team will examine the design concepts you developed during the Emulate step for how well they solve your design challenge in a life-friendly way and for how feasible they are. Although Evaluate is shown as the “last” step in the Design Spiral,

Evaluation should occur multiple times throughout the design process and with increasing rigor. Early in the process, this may be as simple as pausing after you generate a number of ideas to identify which concepts have the most potential and which seem like dead ends. As your team hones in on a concept, evaluation may involve more complex activities, such as creating models, testing technologies, or sharing prototypes with users or stakeholders to solicit feedback.

Tips and suggestions to guide you.

1.

Consider the whole system.

Think about how the design concept is part of a system and how that system is impacted by it. How does your design concept interact with material and energy systems? What about human relationships and behavior? Are there adjacent or super-systems that should be considered, too? (See the Systems View section of this site for an explanation of these terms.)

2.

Identify feasibility constraints.

Consider potential barriers or limitations that your design concept might face (e.g. technology, cost, materials, regulations, culture) and how the solution could be deployed in the real world (e.g. market strategy). Is implementation/adoption of your idea feasible? What are the next steps it would take to achieve your goal?

3.

Evaluate against nature’s unifying patterns.

Use nature’s unifying patterns as an evaluation rubric. Does your design concept incorporate or embody these principles for successful life-friendly design?

4.

Make a prototype.

Make simple prototypes or other visualizations (drawings, storyboards, etc.) for your idea. Doing so can help you recognize problems or opportunities you might have missed and makes it easier to share your ideas with others for feedback. Even low-resolution, non-functional prototypes can be very useful when first testing out concepts.

Rapid Prototyping Methods

IDEO.org’s Design Kit is a great resource for learning about methods for rapidly prototyping and testing ideas.

Paper prototype for UX interface.

Early prototypes need not be functional. You can learn a lot from even simple prototypes made out of paper or cardboard. Storyboarding or diagramming can be extremely helpful as well.

Stakeholder visit in Egypt.

A student from the German University in Cairo interviews a stakeholder in Fayoum, Egypt. The University’s team, Egy-Osmo, developed a camel-inspired irrigation and pest-control strategy that won grand prize in the 2012-13 Biomimicry Student Design Challenge.

5.

Talk to people!

Interview prospective users and stakeholders to understand their reactions to your idea. Get input from experts in the field and learn from their knowledge and experience.

6.

Repeat, repeat, repeat.

Design is a fundamentally iterative process. The best design outcomes often arise when a design team cycles through all of the steps of the Design Spiral many times, improving their design concepts through rapid iteration. (That’s the reason it’s a spiral, not a straight line!) Expect to revisit earlier steps and revise your work as new insights emerge and force you to revisit past assumptions. Don’t get discouraged. Keep going!

Final thoughts

Some of the most popular and inspiring biomimicry case studies can seem almost obvious in their elegance and simplicity, given the elegance evident in many of nature’s solutions. Yet many biomimetic concepts require years of iteration to become commercially successful. In reality, developing a successful biomimetic solution is a complex and challenging journey.

Biomimicry is also a practice, and the more you practice the various steps in a biomimicry design process, the more natural they’ll become and the more quickly you’ll be able to iterate.

Resources

Nature's Patterns Checklist

Use this checklist to assess your design against nature’s unifying patterns.

Business Model Generation (2010)

This book by Alexander Osterwalder & Yves Pigneur introduces the Business Model Canvas, a tool for mapping market strategies that can be especially useful for disruptive innovations.

Rapid Prototyping

IDEO.org’s Design Kit is a great resource for learning about various methods for rapidly prototyping and testing ideas.

Integrating Feedback Video

Check out this video from IDEO.org’s Design Kit for an overview on integrating feedback and iterating your design ideas.

Storyboarding Video

Check out this video from IDEO.org’s Design Kit for an overview on using storyboarding to help visualize your design concept and how it will interact with users.

Keep Going!

You’ve reached the last “step” of the Design Spiral, but the journey isn’t over. Reflect on and revise your work. Revisit previous steps as you continue to learn and improve your design ideas.
Image Credits

Stakeholder interview: Courtesy of Egy-Osmo team
Paper UX mockup:  d_jan CC-BY via Flickr
Paper backpack prototype: Plusea CC-BY via Flickr

GIVE FEEDBACK